Witchy Engagement Rings

183 products

183 products

Valley Rose is the home of Witchy Engagement Rings, where earthly magic meets true love. Our witchy engagement ring designs feature grey diamonds, vintage halo designs, celestial style rings, black gemstones, and vibrant sapphires. Crafted with ethical materials our magical designs are not only stunning but an active force for good. 

Emerald Signet Ring Eye Shaped in Gold with Diamonds By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Emerald Signet Ring Eye Shaped in Gold with Diamonds By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Rhea Signet
$4,200.00
Tapered Pink Ruby Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Tapered Pink Ruby Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Helena Ring, Pink Ruby
$5,210.00
Marquise Lab Diamond Stacked Ethical Wedding Ring By Valley Rose
Marquise Lab Diamond Stacked Ethical Wedding Ring By Valley Rose
Ella Ring
from $1,440.00
Garnet Eternity Ring, Gold Wedding Stacking Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Garnet Eternity Ring, Gold Wedding Stacking Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Paola Eternity Band, 1/2 Ct, Garnet
$2,835.00
Blue Sapphire Eternity Ring, Gold Wedding Stacking Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Blue Sapphire Eternity Ring, Gold Wedding Stacking Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Paola Eternity Band, 1/2 Ct, Blue Sapphire
$3,232.00
Blue Sapphire Eternity Ring, Gold Wedding Stacking Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Blue Sapphire Eternity Ring, Gold Wedding Stacking Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Paola Eternity Band, 1/2 Ct, Medium Blue Sapphire
$3,232.00
Dainty Tapered Garnet Wedding Band, Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Dainty Tapered Garnet Wedding Band, Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Meissa Ring, Garnet
$1,936.00
Textured Blue Sapphire Ring, Mojave Chevron Gold Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Textured Blue Sapphire Ring, Mojave Chevron Gold Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Mojave Ring, Blue Sapphire
$1,440.00
Textured Green Sapphire Ring, Mojave Chevron Gold Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Textured Green Sapphire Ring, Mojave Chevron Gold Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Mojave Ring, Green Sapphire
$1,440.00
Textured Teal Sapphire Ring, Mojave Chevron Gold Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Textured Teal Sapphire Ring, Mojave Chevron Gold Band By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Mojave Ring, Teal Sapphire
$1,440.00
Tapered Garnet Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Tapered Garnet Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Helena Ring, Garnet
$1,885.00
Mini Tapered Red Ruby Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Mini Tapered Red Ruby Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Helena Ring, petite, Red Ruby
$3,695.00
Tapered Red Ruby Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Tapered Red Ruby Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Helena Ring, Red Ruby
$5,210.00
Blue Sapphire Stackable Ethical Wedding Ring By Valley Rose
Blue Sapphire Stackable Ethical Wedding Ring By Valley Rose
Helena Ring, Blue Sapphire
$3,000.00
Mini Tapered Blue Sapphire Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Mini Tapered Blue Sapphire Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Helena Ring, petite, Blue Sapphire
$2,265.00
Mini Tapered Teal Sapphire Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Mini Tapered Teal Sapphire Band - Gold Stacking Ring By Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry
Helena Ring, petite, Teal Sapphire
$2,265.00
Pear Sapphire Three Stone Engagement Ring with Diamonds By Valley Rose
Pear Sapphire Three Stone Engagement Ring with Diamonds By Valley Rose
Angelus Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,200.00
Pear Lab Diamond Wide Band Alternative Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Pear Lab Diamond Wide Band Alternative Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Danu Engagement Ring
$1,700.00
14k Gold Wedding Band V Shaped Ring By Valley Rose
14k Gold Wedding Band V Shaped Ring By Valley Rose
Anu Ring
$525.00
Celestial Orion Constellation Ruby Ring - Ethical Wedding Band By Valley Rose
Celestial Orion Constellation Ruby Ring - Ethical Wedding Band By Valley Rose
Eros Ring
$1,670.00
Diamond Celestial Constellation Eternity Ring By Valley Rose
Diamond Celestial Constellation Eternity Ring By Valley Rose
Galaxy Ring
from $1,900.00
Lab or Recycled Diamond Solitaire Ethical Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Round Diamond and Marquise Diamonds By Valley Rose
Hera Solitaire
from $1,285.00
Emerald Cut Diamond Wide Band Ring Alternative Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Emerald Cut Diamond Wide Band Ring Alternative Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Flidas Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
$1,715.00
Knife Edge Round Lab Diamond Solitaire Alternative Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Knife Edge Round Lab Diamond Solitaire Alternative Engagement Ring By Valley Rose
Fortuna Engagement Ring
$1,200.00
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Marquise Diamonds By Valley Rose
Elain Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,730.00
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Pear Teal Sapphire and split shank By Valley Rose
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Pear Teal Sapphire and split shank By Valley Rose
Faye Pear Teal Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$1,675.00
Celestial Engagement Ring, Unique Marquise Diamond Halo By Valley Rose
Celestial Engagement Ring, Unique Marquise Diamond Halo By Valley Rose
Ellaria Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,730.00
Unique Teal Sapphire Engagement Ring with Diamond Halo By Valley Rose
Unique Teal Sapphire Engagement Ring with Diamond Halo By Valley Rose
Kristina Oval Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$1,675.00
Celestial Engagement Ring Round shape with Diamond Halo and 2ct Round Diamond By Valley Rose
Celestial Engagement Ring Round shape with Diamond Halo and 2ct Round Diamond By Valley Rose
Avaluna Round Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,730.00
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Pear Shape Diamond By Valley Rose
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Pear Shape Diamond By Valley Rose
Serena Pear Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,730.00
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Round Diamond and Marquise Diamonds By Valley Rose
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Round Diamond and Marquise Diamonds By Valley Rose
Rosalin Round Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,730.00
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Pear Shape Teal Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Pear Shape Teal Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Serena Pear Teal Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,730.00
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Round Blue Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Round Blue Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Rosalin Round Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,730.00
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Round Green Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Round Green Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Rosalin Round Green Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,730.00
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Round Teal Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Round Teal Sapphire and Diamonds By Valley Rose
Rosalin Round Teal Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,730.00
Fantasy sapphire and diamonds engagement ring with Pear Blue Sapphire By Valley Rose
Fantasy sapphire and diamonds engagement ring with Pear Blue Sapphire By Valley Rose
Serena Pear Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,730.00
Fantasy Sapphire and Diamonds Engagement Ring with Pear Green Sapphire By Valley Rose
Fantasy Sapphire and Diamonds Engagement Ring with Pear Green Sapphire By Valley Rose
Serena Pear Green Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$2,730.00
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Pear Green Sapphire Diamond Crossover By Valley Rose
Fairytale Engagement Ring with Pear Green Sapphire Diamond Crossover By Valley Rose
Faye Pear Green Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$1,675.00
Unique Engagement Ring with Pear Blue Sapphire Diamond Crossover By Valley Rose
Unique Engagement Ring with Pear Blue Sapphire Diamond Crossover By Valley Rose
Faye Pear Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring, Setting Only
$1,675.00
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Oval Diamond and Marquise Diamonds By Valley Rose
Fantasy Engagement Ring with Oval Diamond and Marquise Diamonds By Valley Rose
Leonora Oval Diamond Engagement Ring
$2,730.00

Artfully Designed Fantasy Engagement Rings

Passionately designed jewelry with deep sentimental value. Heirlooms that transcend generations.

Made one-at-a-time by master jewelers with decades of expertise. Certified ethical materials that are an active force for good.

Works of art, each one made for you. Every piece is designed by Brittany Groshong, Artist and Visionary

Recently viewed

Fantasy Engagement Rings FAQs

Our custom ring builder for our sapphire engagement rings is simple and allows you to create a custom ring from scratch.

1. Select a sapphire and add it to your cart
2. Select your setting and add it to your cart.
3. Once your order is confirmed we custom make your ring from scratch.

Email us at help@valleyrosestudio.com for more customization options.

Yes! We would be happy do do a custom project for you. Email us here help@valleyrosestudio.com to learn more. Or book a virtual appointment with us here.

YES! We keep a selection of loose gemstones here.If you do not see what you need in this collection then reach out to us at help@valleyrosestudio.com for more information.

Since all of our engagement rings are bespoke settings we can custom source you a center stone. We work with lab diamonds, salt and pepper diamonds, recycled diamonds and sapphires. 

If you would like a custom lab diamond email us help@valleyrosestudio.com or put in your checkout notes the grading you would like.

We are a very small jewelry design studio and custom make each engagement ring from scratch. We keep a small inventory of ready to ship designs if you are in a hurry. 

But for all our made to order bespoke styles we custom make them just for you and the process can take up to 8 weeks to ship. If you need a shorter turnaround reach out to us to see if we can do it: help@valleyrosestudio.com.

We take on rush jobs on a case by case basis, and in some cases require a rush processing fee of $100-200.

We work with 14k and 18k fairmined gold in rose gold, yellow gold, or white gold. 14k and 18k refers to the content of gold in the alloy. 14k has 58.3% gold and 18k is 75% gold content. Both Karats are standard alloys for bridal jewelry. Since 18k has slightly more gold content it is technically a bit softer, but offers a much deeper gold color. 14k is the strongest and is a paler gold color. 

Fairmined gold refers to the gold certification that we work with. We work with fairmined certified gold because it is the only gold that is certified ethical by offering fair pair to miners, sustainability improvements to mining operations, and safe toxic chemical handling. 

Still have questions? Need help? Get In touch!

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Step into the Enchanting World of Valley Rose's Fantasy Engagement Rings

At Valley Rose Ethical Jewelry we are design experts in crafting fantasy and fairytale inspired engagement rings. Our company champions the use of responsibly sourced gemstones, fairmined metals, and innovative craftsmanship for a premium ethical ring that is as beautiful as the story of its materials. Step into a world of enchantment with our captivating collection of Fantasy Engagement Rings and Fairytale Rings designs including:

We offer a diverse range of fantasy ring styles including

At the core of our craftsmanship lies an unwavering commitment to sustainability and ethical practices. Our Fantasy and Fairytale Engagement Rings are meticulously crafted with ethical materials such as fairmined gold, recycled diamonds, colorful artisanal gemstones, and lab-grown diamonds.

Custom Fantasy Engagement Rings: The Ultimate In Ethical Luxury

In addition to our semi-customizable fantasy engagement ring collection, Valley Rose also offers custom engagement ring services to get the fantasy ring of your dreams. With a commitment to ethical sourcing and sustainability, our custom engagement rings are crafted with the same dedication to responsible practices and high-quality materials. We provide free consultations at any point in your shopping journey and can assist with determining budget, the best design for your lifestyle and unique aesthetics, diamond & gemstone qualities, and material choices. We provide virtual try-ons to make the online design process as easy as possible, where at the end you get the exact ring you are expecting (or even better!) with no surprises. 


As you embark on this meaningful journey, let Valley Rose be your trusted partner in choosing an engagement ring that not only captures your love story but also contributes to a more ethical and sustainable future.