What Does a Diamond Grading Report Tell You - And What Doesn't It?

Nov 20, 2026

A diamond grading report is one of the most important things to consider when buying an engagement ring. It’s a useful tool for comparing stones, including lab-grown diamonds, but it’s easy to be confused by the terminology. A diamond grading report provides a professional evaluation of the stone’s characteristics, including the 4Cs, but it won’t tell you everything about the stone.

Below, we’re covering what a diamond grading report actually tells you and what it doesn’t.

What Information Does a Diamond Grading Report Include?

Jasmine Marquise Pink Lab Diamond Unique Modern Engagement Ring

Diamond grading reports document the 4Cs:

  • Cut: How the diamond’s proportions and facets interact with light. GIA assigns an overall cut grade to standard, round brilliant diamonds in a D-to-Z color range, with fancy shapes treated differently.
  • Color: Documented on a D-to-Z scale that measures the absence of color (from colorless to light yellow)
  • Clarity: The presence and characteristics of inclusions and blemishes
  • Carat weight: The diamond’s weight (not its visible size).

A diamond grading report may also provide additional information, such as shape, cutting style, polish, measurements, and clarity plot.

Read more: Demystifying Lab vs. Natural Diamonds

What a Diamond Grading Report Doesn’t Tell You

Brisa Oval Diamond Modern Unique Engagement Ring Solitaire By Valley Rose

A diamond grading report won’t tell you everything about the stone. Here are a few exceptions to be aware of:

  • The grade won’t fully capture the stone’s visual appearance and personality, which can be subjective.
  • It won’t show how the stone looks in different lighting and from different angles.
  • The report won’t document whether the inclusions are noticeable to the naked eye, as the clarity grade is recorded during a professional examination.
  • It is not an appraisal, so it will not provide the current market value for the stone.

The best way to use a diamond grading report is to consider it alongside photos and videos of the ring, as well as your own judgement of its overall appearance.

Read more: Why More Couples are Choosing Lab-Grown Diamonds in 2026

Shop Lab-Grown Diamond Engagement Rings at Valley Rose

At Valley Rose, our gemstone finder allows you to select the perfect lab-created diamond for your sustainable engagement ring. Explore our range of pre-designed engagement ring settings or book a virtual 1-on-1 consultation to start designing a custom lab diamond engagement ring.

FAQs for Diamond Grading Reports

Is a Diamond Grading Report the Same as a Certificate?

The terms “diamond grading report” and “certificate” are often used interchangeably, but a grading report is considered a more accurate assessment of the stone’s quality and value.

Does a Diamond Grading Report Tell You How Much a Diamond is Worth?

No, a diamond grading report only documents the characteristics that may influence the diamond’s value. It does not assign a market price, which would require an appraisal.

Can Two Diamonds with the Same Grade Look Different?

Yes, diamonds with similar grades can still look different due to their light performance, visible inclusions, and proportions.

How Can I Check Whether a Diamond Report is Genuine?

Genuine diamond reports will have a verification service that allows you to check that the details of the report match those of the diamond being sold. There may also be a laser-inscribed report number on the stone.

 


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


What's Your Engagement Ring Style