How do I choose an ethical engagement ring?

June 19, 2023

How do I choose an ethical engagement ring?


Choosing an engagement ring is a significant decision that symbolizes love and commitment. However, in today's world, it's not enough for the ring to be beautiful; it should also be ethically sourced and sustainable. With increasing awareness of the environmental and social impact of the jewelry industry, many couples are seeking ethical alternatives for their engagement rings. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the various aspects of ethical engagement rings, from the definition of ethical to the factors to consider when choosing one. Let's dive in and discover how you can make an informed decision and find an engagement ring that aligns with your values.


What Makes an Engagement Ring Ethical?

Before we delve into the details, let's define what an ethical engagement ring means. Ethical engagement rings are crafted with materials that adhere to responsible sourcing practices, minimize environmental impact, and ensure fair labor conditions throughout the supply chain. When choosing an ethical engagement ring, it's essential to consider factors such as:

  1. Responsible Material Sourcing: Ethical engagement rings use materials that are sourced in a manner that respects human rights, supports local communities, and minimizes environmental harm. This includes gemstones and metals.

  2. Conflict-Free Diamonds: Conflict-free diamonds are those that have been mined and traded without financing armed conflicts or human rights abuses. They are certified to be free from conflict and adhere to the Kimberley Process, a global initiative to prevent the trade of conflict diamonds.

  3. Sustainable Gemstones: Sustainable gemstones are those that are mined and cut with minimal environmental impact. They may include lab-grown diamonds, recycled diamonds, or alternative gemstones that are ethically sourced and have a smaller carbon footprint.

  4. Fair Labor Practices: Ethical engagement rings are produced by workers who are treated fairly, paid a living wage, and work in safe conditions. The jewelry industry has a history of exploitative labor practices, so it's crucial to choose brands that prioritize fair treatment of workers.

  5. Transparency and Traceability: Ethical engagement rings come with transparent and traceable supply chains, allowing consumers to know the origin of the materials and ensure they meet ethical standards.

how to choose an ethical engagement ring

Understanding Ethical and Sustainable Gemstones

Gemstones are an integral part of engagement rings, and choosing ethically sourced and sustainable gemstones is essential. Let's explore the different options available:

Conflict-Free Diamonds: A Step Towards Ethical Sparkle

Diamonds have long been the traditional choice for engagement rings, but their sourcing has raised concerns about ethical and environmental issues. Conflict diamonds, also known as blood diamonds, are mined in war zones and sold to finance armed conflicts against governments. This unethical practice has led to human rights abuses and environmental degradation.

To address these concerns, the Kimberley Process Certification Scheme was established in 2003 to ensure that diamonds are sourced from conflict-free areas. The process requires participating countries to implement strict regulations and certify that their diamonds are conflict-free. However, the Kimberley Process has received criticism for its limitations and loopholes, which allow some conflict diamonds to enter the market.

To go beyond conflict-free diamonds, many couples are opting for additional certifications and guarantees, such as:

  • Responsible Jewelry Council (RJC) Certification: The RJC is an international organization that sets standards for responsible business practices in the jewelry industry. RJC-certified brands adhere to ethical, social, and environmental standards throughout their supply chains.
  • SCS Sustainably Rated Certification:The SCS certification program is a 3rd party assessment of diamonds to determine they met a certain a series of Sustainability and Ratings that cover environmental practices and ethical treatment of workers.

While conflict-free diamonds are a step in the right direction, some couples may want to explore alternative options for their engagement rings. Let's explore these alternatives and their sustainability aspects.

aether ethical lab diamond

Lab-Grown Diamonds: A Sparkle Created with Science

Lab-grown diamonds, also known as synthetic or cultured diamonds, are created in a controlled laboratory environment using advanced technology. These diamonds have the same physical, chemical, and optical properties as natural diamonds but are produced through a process that mimics the natural formation of diamonds.

Lab-grown diamonds offer several sustainability benefits:

  1. Reduced Environmental Impact: Lab-grown diamonds have a significantly lower carbon footprint compared to mined diamonds. The energy used in the lab-grown diamond production process can come from renewable sources, further reducing their environmental impact.

  2. Conflict-Free and Ethical: Since lab-grown diamonds are created in a controlled laboratory environment, they are inherently conflict-free and ethically sourced. There are no concerns about human rights abuses or environmental degradation associated with mining.

  3. Traceability and Transparency: Lab-grown diamonds have a transparent supply chain, ensuring traceability and allowing consumers to know the origin of the diamond.

  4. Quality and Affordability: Lab-grown diamonds offer consistent quality and can be more affordable than natural diamonds of similar size and quality.

It's important to note that lab-grown diamonds are relatively new to the market, and their long-term environmental and social impact is still being studied. However, they are considered a promising alternative for those seeking ethical and sustainable engagement rings.

recycled second hand diamond

Recycled Diamonds: Giving New Life to Old Sparkles

Recycled diamonds, also known as repurposed or secondhand diamonds, are diamonds that have been previously used in jewelry and are repurposed for new pieces. These diamonds are sourced from various channels, including estate sales, auctions, and trade-ins.

Choosing recycled diamonds offers the following benefits:

  1. Reduced Environmental Impact: By reusing existing diamonds, the demand for newly mined diamonds is reduced, resulting in a lower environmental impact.

  2. Conflict-Free and Ethical: Recycled diamonds do not contribute to the demand for new diamonds, eliminating the potential support for conflict or unethical mining practices.

  3. Unique and Vintage Appeal: Recycled diamonds often have a unique history and vintage aesthetic, making them a distinctive choice for engagement rings.

Recycled diamonds are a sustainable option that allows you to embrace the beauty of a diamond while minimizing the environmental and ethical concerns associated with newly mined stones.

colored precious ethical gemstone options

Alternative Gemstones: Exploring the Rainbow of Sustainability

Engagement rings don't have to be limited to diamonds. There is a wide range of alternative gemstones that offer both beauty and sustainability. Here are a few popular options:

  1. Sapphires: Sapphires, available in various colors, have gained popularity as an alternative to diamonds. They are durable, ethically sourced, and come in a range of vibrant hues.

  2. Moissanite: Moissanite is a lab-grown gemstone that closely resembles a diamond in appearance. It offers brilliance and fire, making it an attractive alternative for those who want a diamond-like sparkle without the ethical concerns.

  3. Emeralds: Emeralds, known for their rich green color, can make a stunning centerpiece for an engagement ring. It's important to ensure that emeralds are responsibly sourced, as the mining of emeralds can have environmental and social impacts.

  4. Aquamarine: Aquamarine, with its serene blue hue, is a popular choice for those seeking an alternative gemstone. It is relatively abundant and can be responsibly sourced.

When considering alternative gemstones, it's important to research their sourcing practices and choose brands that prioritize ethical and sustainable mining and manufacturing processes.

ethical metal options for engagement rings

Determining Ethical Metal Choices

While gemstones take center stage in engagement rings, the choice of metal is also essential. Let's explore two options for ethical metal choices:

Fairmined Gold: A Golden Opportunity for Ethical Sourcing

Fairmined gold is a certification that ensures gold is responsibly sourced and mined in a manner that supports social development and environmental protection. The certification guarantees that miners receive fair wages, work in safe conditions, and follow environmental standards.

Here are the key benefits of choosing fairmined gold:

  1. Traceability and Transparency: Fairmined gold ensures traceability throughout the supply chain, allowing consumers to know where the gold originated and that it meets ethical standards.

  2. Supporting Communities: Fairmined gold supports small-scale miners and their communities by providing fair wages, better working conditions, and access to education and healthcare.

  3. Environmental Protection: Fairmined gold mining follows strict environmental guidelines to minimize the impact on ecosystems, including responsible waste management and reforestation initiatives.

By choosing engagement rings crafted with fairmined gold, you can support responsible mining practices and contribute to positive social and environmental change.

Recycled Gold: Runner Up Option

Recycled gold, also known as reclaimed gold, is obtained by melting down existing jewelry, gold scraps, or electronic waste and refining it into new pieces. Advocates of recycled gold promise that it reduces the demand for newly mined gold and thus minimizing the environmental impact associated with mining.

But this isn’t the full story. Recycled gold isn't actively eco-friendly because it still needs to be mined in a way at its origin where it contributes to deforestation and polluting of drinking water. This original mining could have occurred within very recent history and these consequences last decades. Additionally it has been proven by leading experts that the current recycled gold industry has zero impact on decreasing the demand for gold mining nor to mention it fails to address how the majority of the world's gold is obtained. 

ethical engagement rings

Making an Informed Purchase: Questions to Ask and Research to Conduct

When purchasing an ethical engagement ring, it's essential to gather information and ask the right questions to ensure that the brand and the ring align with your values. Here are some important considerations:

  1. Brand Research: Conduct thorough research on the brand's values, certifications, and reputation. Look for brands that prioritize ethical sourcing, transparency, and sustainable practices.

  2. Material Origins: Inquire about the origin of the gemstones and metals used in the engagement ring. Ensure they are responsibly sourced, conflict-free, and adhere to recognized certifications or standards.

  3. Supply Chain Transparency: Look for brands that provide transparency and traceability throughout their supply chain. They should be able to provide information on the mining, cutting, and manufacturing processes involved in creating the engagement ring.

  4. Certifications and Standards: Check for certifications such as the Responsible Jewelry Council (RJC) certification, CanadaMark certification, or Fairmined gold certification. These certifications ensure that the brand meets rigorous ethical and sustainability standards.

  5. Labor Practices: Inquire about the brand's labor practices. Ensure that workers are treated fairly, paid a living wage, and work in safe conditions. Look for brands that support artisanal miners and contribute to the well-being of local communities.

  6. Environmental Commitment: Research the brand's environmental policies and initiatives. Look for brands that prioritize environmental conservation, minimize their carbon footprint, and implement sustainable practices throughout their operations.

By asking these questions and conducting thorough research, you can make an informed purchase and choose an engagement ring that represents your values and commitment to ethical and sustainable practices.

oval halo ethical engagement ring

The Future of Ethical Engagement Rings

The demand for ethical engagement rings is growing as more couples prioritize sustainability and ethical considerations in their purchasing decisions. Ethical engagement rings are not just a trend; they represent a shift towards responsible consumption and a desire to make a positive impact on the world.

As consumers, we have the power to drive change in the jewelry industry by supporting brands that prioritize ethical sourcing, sustainable practices, and transparency. By choosing ethical engagement rings, we can contribute to the well-being of communities, protect the environment, and ensure a brighter future for all.

ethical custom engagement ring design services


Choosing an ethical engagement ring is a journey that requires careful consideration, research, and understanding of the various aspects involved. By opting for conflict-free diamonds, sustainable gemstones, and ethical metal choices, you can create a symbol of love that aligns with your values and makes a positive impact.

Remember to ask questions, conduct research, and choose brands that prioritize transparency, fair labor practices, and environmental responsibility. Whether you choose a lab-grown diamond, a recycled diamond, or an alternative gemstone, your ethical engagement ring represents not only your commitment to each other but also your commitment to a more sustainable and equitable world.

Embrace the beauty of ethical engagement rings and let your love story shine with a ring that reflects your values and the future you envision.

Additional Information: The ethical engagement ring industry is continuously evolving, with new certifications, technologies, and practices emerging. It's essential to stay informed and keep up with the latest developments in ethical sourcing and sustainability.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Sizing & Care

Ring Sizing Guide

Print and download this chart to find your ring size. Make sure you use exactly 8.5"x11" letter paper. You can use a string or a piece of paper and wrap around your finger or nuckle to measure the circumference and match to your size.

Brilliant Earth Ring Sizing Guide ↠


Necklace Sizing Guide

Follow this chart to see where the necklace will fall. All necklace sizes are described on the product pages. We suggest getting a piece of string and measuring necklace on your neck to ensure best fit. 


Special Care Instructions

To keep your jewels looking their best please keep these tips in mind to extend the life of your pieces. 

RuffRuff App RuffRuff App by Tsun